woodland garden with fall colors in oranges and golds with boulder in center and green groundcover

Fall is For Planting – or is it?

I’m sure you have heard the phrase “Fall is for Planting.” And it’s true. Autumn is a popular time to install perennials, trees and shrubs. Temperatures are more comfortable for working outdoors and plants are less likely to dehydrate in the burning sun and heat.

But there are some caveats homeowners and their landscapers need to be aware of, especially when it comes to planting trees and shrubs. While many woody plants establish successfully in autumn, some species are particularly sensitive to fall digging and transplanting. Known as fall dig hazards, these plants may struggle to grow new roots before winter, leaving them vulnerable to dehydration, winter injury, and even death. That’s why it’s important to understand which specimens pose the highest risk and why timing matters.

photo of tree roots on a freshly dug tree
When a landscaper digs a tree, roots are inevitably severed and must regenerate upon planting.

When it comes to transplanting trees in the fall, moisture is everything. When a tree is dug for transplanting, it loses a significant portion of its root system. With fewer roots available to absorb water, the tree must work harder to maintain the moisture it needs to survive.

For fall-dug trees, damaged roots cannot always replace the water lost through the branches, twigs, and foliage. This becomes especially concerning during winter, when cold temperatures, frozen soil, and drying winds can cause winter desiccation. If the tree or shrub loses moisture faster than it can replenish it, branches may die back, foliage may turn brown, and the entire plant may fail.

Which Trees Are Considered Fall Dig Hazards?

Common fall dig hazard trees make up a fairly expansive list:

    • Maples and related species: Acer (maple)
    • Birch and hornbeam: Betula (birch), Carpinus (hornbeam)
    • Hackberry and redbud: Celtis (hackberry), Cercis (redbud)
    • Dogwood and beech: Cornus (dogwood), Fagus (beech)
    • Honeylocust and sweetgum: Gleditsia (honeylocust), Liquidambar (sweetgum)
    • Tuliptree and magnolia: Liriodendron (tuliptree), Magnolia
    • Crabapple and blackgum: Malus (crabapple), Nyssa (blackgum)
    • Sycamore and flowering trees: Platanus (sycamore), Prunus (cherry and plum)
    • Oaks: Quercus (oak), with pin oak generally considered an exception to this group
    • Willow and silver linden: Salix (willow), Tilia tomentosa (silver linden)
    • Elm and zelkova: Ulmus (elm), Zelkova
    • Leyland cypress and Cryptomeria: Cupressus × leylandii (Leyland cypress), Cryptomeria

This list is a guide to species that may be more challenging to transplant in autumn, not a guarantee that every tree within these groups will fail. Results depend on species, cultivar, tree size, root condition, soil temperature, weather, and how the tree was grown and handled.

If you truly have your heart set on planting a tree this fall from the dig hazard list, don’t fret. You can seek out a container-grown plant or one that was dug earlier in the year.

Selection of plants and trees in a nursery in containers
Nurseries often carry container grown material, so clients have options for fall planting without worrying about a fall-dig hazard.
inside of empty plastic container lined in copper
Copper lined containers are particularly helpful since they prevent roots from girdling.
tree in a fabric grow bag with a second one in the background
Grow bags provide an alternative to plastic containers but serve the same purpose.

Broadleaf Evergreens: A Special Concern

Broadleaf evergreens and some conifers (Leyland Cypress and Cryptomeria) also deserve attention when planning fall planting. Unlike deciduous trees, which drop their leaves in autumn, broadleaf evergreens and conifers retain their foliage throughout the winter. Their leaves and twigs continue to lose moisture, even when cold weather slows the plant’s normal processes.

If a newly transplanted evergreen has not established enough new roots to replace that lost moisture, it can dry out during prolonged cold, windy periods. The problem is compounded when the ground freezes. The roots may be surrounded by soil containing moisture, but that water is not readily available for uptake when temperatures are too low or the soil is frozen.

For these reasons, many broadleaf evergreens and select conifers are best dug/transplanted in spring, when conditions are more favorable for root recovery and establishment. My rule of thumb for Zone 7 (where I live), is to plant container grown woodies no later than the end of October.

Aucuba plant with yellow spots on dark green glossy foliage
Broadleaf evergreens like this Aucuba need special attention if planted in the fall.

The most practical approach to dealing with fall dig hazards is to work with your nursery or landscaper to assess risk and make the proper selection in terms of plant material and timing. Be sure to excavate for a root flare if one isn’t evident and water deeply at least a couple of times a week to help your new plant settle in. If you follow professional guidance, you’ll be rewarded with plants that thrive not only during their first winter, but for years to come.

Lasting Landscapes by Carol

Combating Climate Change by Planting Trees

I find myself constantly concerned about climate change which the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) says is increasing the odds of severe weather events. In my own backyard I’ve lost trees and experienced property damage at least three times in the last 18 months due to straight line winds and tornadic activity. In addition to the violent storms that are eliminating mature trees, pests like the Emerald Ash Borer, which is attacking Ash trees, and Bacterial Leaf Scorch, which is killing off Red Oaks, add to the elimination of the soldiers in our forests and neighborhoods.

Lasting Landscapes by Carol
An Ash tree dying from Ash Borer infestation

Multiple scientific studies encourage tree planting as a way to combat climate change by sequestering carbon and helping to offset human-caused green gas omissions. Experts debate whether the strategy of planting trees is the most effective solution and some argue that more analysis is required before fully implementing a strategy. I guess I’m somewhat impatient on this topic since I don’t like the idea of waiting for more information while our forests fail and our world overheats.

I believe the time is now for us to plant trees. It’s something each one of us can do. We can all contribute and lucky for us fall is a great time to plant.

If you have the space for a large tree, consider a Sugar Maple (Acer saccharum) or a White Oak (Quercus alba). Although I won’t be here to see them grow to maturity, I’ll be planting some White Oak seedlings this fall as a succession plan for some of my large trees which are in decline or have been gravely damaged by storms.

Lasting Landscapes by Carol
A White Oak seedling

If you’d prefer a medium sized tree, consider a Kentucky Coffee Tree (Gymnocladus dioicus), a Redbud (Cercis canadensis), Persian Ironwood (Parrotia persica ‘Vanessa’) or Korean Sweetheart Tree (Euscaphis japonica). I have installed all four of these trees on my property in the last twelve months.

Lasting Landscapes by Carol
The Kentucky Coffee Tree provides wonderful shade and structure with minimal leaf litter
Lasting Landscapes by Carol
Cercis canadensis ‘Flamethrower’ in the landscape

Have a tiny home or lot?  What about Chinese Fringtree (Chionanthus retusus) or Columnar Sugar Maple (Acer saccharum ‘Monumentale’). Yep, I planted those too!

Lasting Landscapes by Carol
Acer ‘Monumentale’ only gets two feet wide, but grows twenty feet tall

Any of these amazing trees (and many others) will not only benefit the environment but also beautify your space and bring you years of enjoyment. And that’s a strategy I’m hoping we can all support.